A Theory of Moral Objectivity
By Robert M. Ellis, originally written as a Ph.D. thesis 'A Buddhist theory of moral objectivity' in 2001. This html version copyright 2008.
Testimonial on the thesis by the external examiner
A hard-copy paperback book of this thesis is now available from lulu.com and also on Amazon, price UK£25 (or equivalent). This relatively high cost is necessary because it is A4 size and has 487 pages (296,000 words). This print version includes an index.
A downloadable pdf version of this thesis is available from the British Library at http://ethos.bl.uk (you will need to search the original title 'A Buddhist theory of moral objectivity', and register with the ethos site, but registration is open and the download pdf is free for researchers). Alternatively you can download a pdf for a small cost from lulu.com.
Notes on this web version:
PART 1: CRITIQUE OF DUALISM
i) “Buddhist”
ii) “Moral”
iii) “Objectivity”
b) Outline of overall methodi) Non-dualism and metaphysical agnosticism
ii) The relation of theory and practice
iii) Absolute value and the judgements of conventional logic
iv) The use of psychological premises
v) Timeless truth in historical contexts
vi) The Middle Way and its antecedents
2. The psychological basis of dualism
a) The psychological basis of belief
i) Against initial philosophical objections to the unconscious
ii) Belief and desire
iii) Desire and the ego
iv) The nature of dualistic belief processes
v) Some evidence from social psychology
i) The heuristic problem
ii) The failure of dualistic approaches to the problem
iii) A psychological explanation without relativism
c) Psychological basis and philosophical expression
i) Dogmatism and scepticism
ii) The dualism/non-dualism distinction
iii) Representationalism and expressivism
iv) Linguistic idealism
3. The failure of the dualistic model of ethics: (1) Eternalism
a) Introduction to dualistic ethics
i) Ethical foundationalism
ii) Cosmic justice
iii) Freewill
iv) Alienation of desire
v) Political polarisation
c) Introduction to the historical survey
i) Socrates’ aporesis
ii) Socratic eternalism
iii) Platonic eternalism
iv) Platonic conservatism
i) Stoic non-dualism
ii) Stoic Dualism: the Cosmic Logos
iii) Stoic Dualism: the Individual Logos
i) The Law of the Torah
ii) Jesus
iii) Paul
iv) Early Christianity and Stoicism
v) Constantine and Christian political philosophy
vi) Christian mysticism and religious experience
vii) The medieval period and the Renaissance
viii) Luther and the Reformation
ix) Descartes
x) Christianity and Capitalism
i) Kant’s background and psychology
ii) Dualism and non-dualism in Kant
iii) Representationalism/ Expressivism
iv) Linguistic idealism
v) Freewill
vi) Ethical Foundationalism
vii) Cosmic Justice
viii) From Conservatism to Liberalism
i) Enlightenment and Romanticism
ii) Hegel’s Dialectic
iii) Pure thought, representations and idealism
iv) Freewill and ethical foundationalism
v) Cosmic justice
vi) Hegel and Totalitarianism
i) The priority of sociology
ii) Methodological holism
iii) Idealism and ideology
iv) Ethical foundationalism and cosmic justice
v) Freewill and determinism
i) Schopenhauer’s context and character
ii) Schopenhauer’s non-dualism
iii) The Principle of Sufficient Reason
iv) Cosmic justice and freewill
v) Ethical foundationalism
i) A capitalist form of eternalism
ii) The epistemological foundations
iii) Compatibilism
iv) Consequentialism and alienation
v) Utilitarianism and politics
4. The failure of the dualistic model of ethics: (2) Nihilism
i) Ethical coherentism
ii) The denial of freewill or cosmic justice
iii) Hedonism and alienation
iv) Individualism
b) The classical roots of nihilism (Scepticism and Aristotle)
i) Classical Scepticism
ii) Aristotle’s empiricism
iii) Aristotle’s ethics
iv) MacIntyre’s reformed Aristotelianism
i) The beginning of modern nihilism
ii) Ideas and impressions
iii) Belief and causality
iv) The denial of the self
v) Ethical descriptivism
i) Scientism from Hume to Frege
ii) Frege
iii) Logical positivism
iv) Positivist ethics
v) Hare
vi) Theories of rationality
vii) Liberal neutrality
i) Grammatical scientism
ii) Theory of meaning
iii) Private language
i) General features of pragmatism
ii) Peirce and James on truth
iii) James’s psychology
iv) Dewey’s psychological ethics
v) Dewey’s political thought
i) Nietzsche’s “nihilism”
ii) The Will to Power
iii) The Übermensch
i) Kierkegaard’s leap
ii) Husserl
iii) Heidegger
iv) Sartre
v) Sartre versus Freud
vi) The Postmodern Condition
PART 2: AN ACCOUNT OF NON-DUALISM
5. The psychological basis of the Middle Way
i) Outline of method in Part 2
ii) The Middle Way in Western thought
iii) Introduction to chapter 5
i) Frustration
ii) Papañca
as evidence of frustrationiii) Integration of desires
i) Meaning and desire
ii) The fragmentation of meaning
iii) The integration of meaning
i) Belief, desire, meaning and stream-entry
ii) Doubt
iii) Confidence
i) Cultivating integration of attention
ii) Cultivating integration of emotion
iii) Narrative and archetype
iv) Friendship
v) Sceptical argument and the cultivation of wisdom
f) Temporary and permanent integrations
i) Temporary integrations
ii) Permanent partial integration
iii) Enlightenment
6. The Philosophy of the Middle Way
a) Metaphysical agnosticism and psychological integration
i) Metaphysical agnosticism
ii) Desires and objective integration
iii) Continuity and discontinuity
iv) The uses and abuses of duality
b) The Middle Way in philosophical problems
i) Supervenience
ii) Realism and idealism
iii) Mind and body
iv) Identity
v) Freewill and determinism
vi) Cosmic justice
vii) The unity of the virtues
viii) Positive and negative freedom
c) Verification and falsification
i) Verification and falsification incrementalised
ii) Verification of the Middle Way
iii) Falsification of the Middle Way
d) The individual and the group
i) Two forms of individuality
ii) The integration of groups
iii) Group epistemology
iv) The individual in the group
7. The Normativity of the Middle Way
i) The question of normativity
ii) Rational normativity
iii) The normativity of desire
iv) The normativity of conventions
i) Aesthetic and symbolic normativity
ii) Scientific normativity
8. The Ethics of the Middle Way
i) Ignorance and the need for moral authority
ii) Authority from past integration
iii) Spiritual friendship
iv) Moral traditions
v) Moral precepts
vi) Buddhist precepts
b) Issues in the application of precepts
i) Problems of priority
ii) Consequentialism and deontology
iii) Pride, guilt and confession
i) The justification of political authority
ii) The integration of government
iii) Conflicts between moral and political authority
i) Non-dualism in ten points
ii) The status of the argument
10. Appendix: Issues of compatibility with the Buddhist tradition
i) The epistemological starting-point
ii) Conditioned co-production (
paticcasamuppada)iii) Karma and rebirth
iv) “Sudden” enlightenment
v) Going for Refuge to the Three Jewels